FIRST READING: New immigration spike will instantly erase any gains on jobs, housing, health care

While I am not a fan of the government’s approach, this is overly alarmist as the number of new residents is only about a quarter of the total given that about 50 percent of those captured in IRCC Permanent Residents statistics are also here in Canada and transitioning from temporary to permanent status. Sloppy analysis:

….Not all of the new permanent residents and temporary migrants will need a job, of course. Some are international students without work permits. And an estimated 81,000 permanent immigrants will be spouses, children and grandparents joining a family member already in the country.

But even the most conservative estimates from the new immigration targets are that at least half a million jobs will be needed to sustain the overall influx.

Of the 580,000 permanent immigrants slated for approval in the coming year, 344,700 are being approved on “economic” grounds, meaning they’re slated to fill a job in Canada. Of the temporary migrants slated for arrival, 220,000 will be entering Canada with work permits.

All told, that represents 564,700 jobs. Or, about 47,058 jobs per month, 1,547 jobs per day, 64 jobs per hour.

In the entirety of 2025, Canada gained just 151,000 jobs; the employment level went from 20,993,000 in January to 21,144,000 in December.

At that rate, it would take just three months of immigration under the new targets to account for every job created in 2025.

And the most current labour force figures show that unemployment is going up, not down. In October alone, Canada lost 4,700 jobs….

Source: FIRST READING: New immigration spike will instantly erase any gains on jobs, housing, health care

Unknown's avatarAbout Andrew
Andrew blogs and tweets public policy issues, particularly the relationship between the political and bureaucratic levels, citizenship and multiculturalism. His latest book, Policy Arrogance or Innocent Bias, recounts his experience as a senior public servant in this area.

One Response to FIRST READING: New immigration spike will instantly erase any gains on jobs, housing, health care

  1. Raphael Solomon's avatar Raphael Solomon says:

    “In economics, the lump of labour fallacy is the misconception that there is a finite amount of work—a lump of labour—to be done within an economy.” — Wikipedia.

    Mr. Hopper has succumbed to the lump of labour fallacy: he seems to believe that when new immigrants come into Canada, they take jobs that would have otherwise been occupied by Canadians. Never mind the fact that immigrants are frequently willing to take jobs that other Canadians are not. When 500,000 additional people come into an economy, they also increase aggregate demand (as Keynes might have said), and create the opportunities for more jobs.

    Furthermore, the observation that this number of immigrants is more than the population of some provinces and territories is correct but irrelevant. These immigrants aren’t all going to PEI or Nunavut.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.