Large majority ‘concerned’ about Carney’s hiked immigration targets: poll

Likely reflects reality as well as how question posed and context:

…The increase in numbers, to 580,000 from 380,000 next year, raised concerns for those who took the Leger poll.

Conservative voters were the most concerned about the higher targets, at 94 per cent, followed by supporters of the Bloc Québécois, at 88 per cent. However, a majority of Liberal voters (61 per cent) and New Democrat supporters (58 per cent) also said they were concerned.

Respondents said their main concern was that the larger number of permanent residents would lead to overcrowding in health care and pressure on the education system (the top concerns for 37 per cent of those polled) as well as higher costs of housing given increased demand (21 per cent).

Another 14 per cent said they worry increased immigration will also worsen societal challenges like homelessness and crime, and 11 per cent said they worry it will be harder for people to find work.

Enns said the business community is still looking to immigration as a solution to persistent skilled labour shortages.

But he said the federal government hasn’t communicated well with Canadians about why it’s choosing to increase immigration levels.

“In all the conversation around building Canada and our self-sustaining economy, getting more independent from the U.S., there was an opportunity in that conversation to, I would suggest, reposition the immigration discussion,” he said….

Source: Large majority ‘concerned’ about Carney’s hiked immigration targets: poll

McQueen | Mark Carney should require ‘permanent residents’ to be more permanent

Number of days change doesn’t appear at first glance to violate mobility rights. Dissenting opinions welcome:

…A partial solution to restoring broad support for our immigration system would be to return to first principles and reform the very foundation of the permanent resident program. What’s the point of handing out a million new PR permits over the next 24 months if these lucky individuals are required to spend only 146 days per year in Canada over the next five years, as is currently the case? Let’s change that back to at least 181 days per year in Canada (as was the law for decades) and ensure they’re taxed as residents.

How can we benefit from their “needed skills” if they’re spending 60 per cent of the calendar year working or travelling abroad? Unlike in the United States, where the Green Card permanent residency program expires after 10 years, PR in Canada is for life.

When the new targets were announced, Carney said temporary residents have been working for the same employers and living in the same communities for years, making them permanent residents “in all respects.”

One key step toward restoring confidence in the immigration system would be to require “permanent residents” to spend at least 181 days per year in Canada (as was the case for decades) and to be taxed as residents.

If these workers are truly essential to “Build Canada Strong,” then prove it. Surely it’s not too much to require our new peers to actually live and pay tax in Canada?

Source: Opinion | Mark Carney should require ‘permanent residents’ to be more permanent

FIRST READING: New immigration spike will instantly erase any gains on jobs, housing, health care

While I am not a fan of the government’s approach, this is overly alarmist as the number of new residents is only about a quarter of the total given that about 50 percent of those captured in IRCC Permanent Residents statistics are also here in Canada and transitioning from temporary to permanent status. Sloppy analysis:

….Not all of the new permanent residents and temporary migrants will need a job, of course. Some are international students without work permits. And an estimated 81,000 permanent immigrants will be spouses, children and grandparents joining a family member already in the country.

But even the most conservative estimates from the new immigration targets are that at least half a million jobs will be needed to sustain the overall influx.

Of the 580,000 permanent immigrants slated for approval in the coming year, 344,700 are being approved on “economic” grounds, meaning they’re slated to fill a job in Canada. Of the temporary migrants slated for arrival, 220,000 will be entering Canada with work permits.

All told, that represents 564,700 jobs. Or, about 47,058 jobs per month, 1,547 jobs per day, 64 jobs per hour.

In the entirety of 2025, Canada gained just 151,000 jobs; the employment level went from 20,993,000 in January to 21,144,000 in December.

At that rate, it would take just three months of immigration under the new targets to account for every job created in 2025.

And the most current labour force figures show that unemployment is going up, not down. In October alone, Canada lost 4,700 jobs….

Source: FIRST READING: New immigration spike will instantly erase any gains on jobs, housing, health care

Geist: Jewish students are telling the same story everywhere. Only Canada refuses to listen

Of note:

…The Canadian record is particularly troubling. The House of Commons Justice Committee recommended a national review of campus antisemitism, but it was never conducted. One study commissioned by the former federal Special Envoy on antisemitism documented 781 incidents in Ontario schools, nearly one in six of which involved a teacher or a school-sanctioned activity, with almost half of those reported to school authorities never investigated. A second found that 95.7 per cent of Jewish students surveyed reported experiencing or witnessing antisemitism in the previous year and 70 per cent said their university did not take it seriously. The Special Envoy’s office was abolished in February, six months before the campus study was released.

This leaves governments to use the regulatory and financial power that universities and school boards cannot ignore. Australia’s antisemitism envoy issued a new report last month that identifies the drivers of antisemitism, including what it calls modern, progressive antisemitism, and has established a university report card to name and shame those that fail to act.

Universities Canada recently responded with a five-point plan calling for a national response, stronger enforcement, and better data, though it includes no definition of antisemitism and no timeline. Nolan Quinn, Ontario’s Minister of Colleges, Universities, Research Excellence and Security, has signalled his impatience with the lack of action, issuing an updated university directive in September that puts funding at risk for systemic failure to act. The directive has potential, but it also lacks a definition of antisemitism or a deadline for compliance.

The numerous studies on antisemitism in education confirm both that there is a global problem and that universities and school boards have proven incapable of fixing it themselves. Governments must therefore shift from identifying the problem to asking why those institutions are failing to respond. Provincial governments should commission independent reviews of education system responses to antisemitism, and the federal government should restore the Special Envoy’s office with the mandate to ask what is happening to Jewish students and the power to hold institutions publicly to account.

Source: Jewish students are telling the same story everywhere. Only Canada refuses to listen

Immigration: 380 000 ou 662 000 nouveaux résidents permanents ?

Less commentary in Québec media and this one is more an explainer than commentary:

…Le Québec risque-t-il de recevoir des immigrants qu’il n’a pas choisis ?

C’est ce que craint la vice-première ministre Catherine Gentilcore. Une personne qui obtient sa résidence permanente dans une autre province pourrait ensuite venir s’établir au Québec, sans être comptabilisée dans les cibles québécoises.

Mais les déplacements se font dans les deux sens. Et le Québec perd davantage de résidents au profit des autres provinces qu’il n’en gagne en provenance de celles-ci. Selon l’Institut de la statistique du Québec, 30 237 personnes ont quitté le Québec pour une autre province en 2025, alors que 21 154 ont fait le trajet inverse. Une perte nette de 9083 personnes.

Catherine Xhardez rappelle par ailleurs que le Québec dispose de pouvoirs considérables en immigration. Le gouvernement sélectionne ses immigrants économiques, fixe ses propres seuils d’admission permanente, et n’est pas soumis aux seuils fédéraux. Il peut donc décider de faciliter l’accès à la résidence permanente aux travailleurs étrangers déjà établis sur son territoire.

Pourquoi Ottawa veut-il accorder la résidence permanente à autant de personnes ?

Parce que le système d’immigration est engorgé. Et qu’Ottawa cherche à réduire le nombre de résidents temporaires.

Catherine Xhardez explique que des milliers de personnes attendent depuis longtemps la résidence permanente : des travailleurs dont les permis vont expirer, des familles séparées et des réfugiés déjà reconnus. Tant que ces dossiers occupent les places disponibles, les nouvelles politiques de sélection ne peuvent pas produire leurs effets.

Parisa Mahboubi s’inquiète toutefois des conséquences de cette stratégie. En multipliant les possibilités de passer du statut temporaire au statut permanent, Ottawa risque, selon elle, d’envoyer un mauvais message.

Les immigrants temporaires pourraient en conclure qu’il suffit « de trouver un moyen de rester le plus longtemps possible au Canada, car le gouvernement va vous ouvrir une voie et vous accorder le statut d’immigrant permanent », dit-elle….

Source: Immigration: 380 000 ou 662 000 nouveaux résidents permanents ?

…Is Quebec at risk of receiving immigrants that it didn’t choose?

That is what Vice-Prime Minister Catherine Gentilcore fears. A person who obtains permanent residence in another province could then come to settle in Quebec, without being counted among the Quebec targets.

But movements are happening in both directions. And Quebec is losing more residents to other provinces than it is gaining from them. According to the Institute of Statistics of Quebec, 30,237 people left Quebec for another province in 2025, while 21,154 traveled in the opposite direction. A net loss of 9,083 people.

Catherine Xhardez also reminds that Quebec has considerable powers in immigration. The government selects its economic immigrants, sets its own permanent admission thresholds, and is not subject to federal thresholds. It can therefore decide to facilitate access to permanent residence for foreign workers already established on its territory.

Why does Ottawa want to grant permanent residency to so many people?

Because the immigration system is overwhelmed. And because Ottawa is trying to reduce the number of temporary residents.

Catherine Xhardez explains that thousands of people have been waiting for the permanent residence for a long time: workers whose permits are about to expire, separated families, and already recognized refugees. As long as these cases occupy the available places, the new selection policies cannot take effect.

Parisa Mahboubi, however, is concerned about the consequences of this strategy. By increasing the possibilities of transitioning from temporary status to permanent status, Ottawa, according to her, risks sending a wrong message.

Temporary immigrants might conclude that it is enough to “find a way to stay in Canada for as long as possible, because the government will open a path for you and grant you permanent immigrant status,” she says….

Lavoie: Youth rage, burning bright. What hand could tame thy generational asymmetry?

True:

…Raising immigration is not a sustainable solution. Immigrants age too, and the scale needed to keep this ratio from growing would exceed our capacity to integrate newcomers. Population aging strains any pay-as-you-go program that mainly benefits older people, since fewer people pay in while more draw out. Public pensions and health care are prime examples….

Ultimately, we must improve our institutions so that policies are evaluated for their long-term generational impact. It is far from clear that many of the recently announced budget measures will have significant effects on economic growth and future generations, despite the debt burden it leaves them.

Any policy should balance the needs of young and old without hurting fairness within each generation. The challenge is that governments are tempted to favour older, as well as richer, voters, whose share of the electorate and political influence keep growing.

Source: Youth rage, burning bright. What hand could tame thy generational asymmetry?

Wilczynski: Canada’s new National Security Strategy doesn’t specifically address antisemitism—that’s a problem

From a former colleague whose post-public servant career focus in antisemitism and LGBTQ. Screening for organization affiliation or behaviour is hard but legitimate to argue for more effective screening:

…We must recognize that in many countries, antisemitism is integrated into their educational systems. We must keep this reality in mind as Canada remains open to immigration necessary to foster economic growth. Ensuring we have the capability to assess the threats emanating from antisemitic indoctrination around the world must be built into effective screening systems for all immigrants to Canada.

…Strengthen screening of individuals seeking entry into Canada, improve information-sharing, and accelerate the process of removing individuals found inadmissible. Too many members of listed terrorist organizations, particularly the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, have landed in Canada. They continue to pose a heightened threat to Canadian security. Cursory screening of immigration from countries where the curriculum is persistently and overtly antisemitic or where membership of listed terrorist organizations is endemic poses a significant risk in bringing in people already radicalized against Jews. CSIS, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada, and the Canada Border Services Agency need to share information more effectively to improve screening of individuals who pose a national security threat and to pursue those who have entered illegally so they can be removed from Canada….

Source: Canada’s new National Security Strategy doesn’t specifically address antisemitism—that’s a problem

NP View: Carney’s expanded immigration plan is crashing our quality of life

More unsurprising commentary from the Post:

…On housing, municipalities and provinces need to get over their hangups about densification and do away with policies that prevent cities from expanding outward. The entire country should follow the lead of Albertans, who voted for a number of measures in the recent referendum to ensure that temporary residents will not be able to free-ride off the province’s lavish social welfare system.

And the federal government needs to do a much better job of prioritizing skilled immigrants and do everything possible to ensure that anyone who wants to come to this country does not harbour terrorist sympathies and shares basic liberal values, such as freedom, democracy, multiculturalism and a healthy respect for women’s and gay rights. The number of people admitted each year should be wholly dependent on our capacity to do thorough background checks on each and every one of them.

These are all things that are eminently worth doing, because this is a place that was built with the blood, sweat and tears of people who came in search of a better life — and those are exactly the type of people Canada will need if it hopes to become a global leader in the future.

Source: NP View: Carney’s expanded immigration plan is crashing our quality of life

And a similar op-ed in the Post:

…Newcomers will be impacted, too, facing the same shortages with even fewer resources to fall back on, and they will find the country they encounter bears little resemblance to the one they were promised when they crossed the world to join it.

There is nothing humane about bringing people into Canada faster than the government can provide them with the conditions for a decent life. The Liberal record on immigration represents a betrayal of the Canadian dream, both for the existing citizenry and newcomers alike.

Canada is supposed to be a place where if you are willing to work hard, you can expect to find a good job, support yourself, buy a home, and start a family. But that is not the case for countless Canadians, and it hasn’t been for quite some time.

Immigration policy must serve the Canadian Dream, not undermine it. For 11 years, the Liberals have prioritized masking economic stagnation and meeting corporate demand for cheap labour over the common good. This is not simply bad governance, it is a moral failure and a betrayal of the Canadian people. Conservatives must help them see it for what it is.

Source: Ryan Thorpe: The Liberal record on immigration represents a betrayal of the Canadian dream

Margaret Atwood: Eh, is for Canadian arts and culture

Always a pleasure reading Atwood for both substance and wit:

…I leave you with the two problems I have presented : “proliferation and shrinkage” — too many mouths to feed and not enough to feed them with — and “curation” — who decides what’s good, and also who’s good. And who decides what’s good for society, which is often a different question. This last problem was not unknown to the Victorians. Nor to whoever wrote the self-censoring film industry Hayes Code of 1934, which begins, “No picture shall be produced which will lower the moral standards of those who see it,” and which explains all those twin beds in the bedrooms of married couples in films of the 1950s. The classical Greeks were also engaged with this kind of censorship issue: Socrates was forced to kill himself in the name of the greater good. But now “good art” versus “good for society” is a problem of our time in the world of the arts.

Neither of these problems are for me to solve, nor are they for those who work in the arts to solve by themselves. Yes, they facilitate and support the work of primary artists and decide which primary artists are allowed through present-day gateways. And if those gateways become too narrow, exclusionary, and negative, new artists will create fresh gateways. They always have. It’s the primary artists themselves — artists of all sizes, shapes, ages, vocations and identities — who will, we hope, break free of unreasonably limiting constraints and show us, once more, what the creative psyche teamed with that elusive entity, the human imagination, is capable of, here and now, in Canada — where the arts have been gifted a new opportunity.

As in the 1960s and ‘70s, Canadians are again excited about their country. There’s nothing like a threat to something you’ve taken for granted — Canadian sovereignty — to awaken the defend-the-nest instinct. It’s the arts that largely define the meaning of a culture to the people living in it.

Largely, but not entirely. What we eat, drink, wear, love and say to our pals is part of that culture too, eh? Yes, we’re facing an existential threat from the chaotic administration of our ponderous neighbour to the south. Yes, we need to diversify trade and beef up our neglected though once widely-admired military. Yes, there will be some belt-tightening, but Canadians have done that before. Will we have to eat more turnips? (They’re not that bad.)

On the plus side, I’ve never seen the country so unified. We’re standing on guard! Alberta is still one of us, Elbows Up is still a thing, we’re passing on the Florida vacations, we’re drinking rye and Scotch instead of bourbon, we’re reading the origin labels in grocery stores, and we hope the Blue Tsunami down south will ameliorate the tariff situation, even if not tomorrow. And we’re asserting, once more, that we exist in our own right, not as a subsidiary of somewhere else.

Mark Carney’s recent budget shows expanded allocations for culture. That’s smart, because culture in its wider sense is the glue that holds a country together, and what tells people in other countries who we are and how high we can jump. We’ve travelled far since the 1960s. When I was first doing international book tours, back in the ‘70s, an English wag said to me, “Canadian culture! Isn’t that an oxymoron?” I don’t think anyone would say that now.

Source: Opinion | Margaret Atwood: Eh, is for Canadian arts and culture

Akbar: Canada wants to rebuild its manufacturing sector, but it’s losing the immigrant workers it needs

Of note. Likely partially due to seniority issues:

….Manufacturing employment fell by only about three per cent between January 2025 and April 2026. But Statistics Canada’s Labour Force Survey shows a more substantial change in who holds those jobs.

Monthly estimates for smaller population groups can fluctuate considerably, but the pattern points to a growing disadvantage for immigrant workers.

Immigrants’ share of manufacturing employment slipped from just over 30 per cent to under 28 per cent by December 2025, and has recovered only slightly since.

The losses have come in waves. In 2025, immigrant workers accounted for a growing share of manufacturing job losses, before Canadian-born workers also began experiencing more layoffs as trade pressures persisted. By April 2026, immigrants remained disproportionately affected.

Nearly two-thirds of unemployed immigrants who had previously worked in manufacturing reported losing their jobs, compared with fewer than half of their Canadian-born counterparts, even as job loss became a less common reason for unemployment across the sector.

These losses also appear more permanent. More than half of unemployed immigrant manufacturing workers reported a permanent layoff in April 2026, compared with about 43 per cent of Canadian-born workers….

Source: Canada wants to rebuild its manufacturing sector, but it’s losing the immigrant workers it needs