Some critic commentary on the “one-time” measure:
….Critics say that the Carney government has reneged on its promise to control immigration, while proponents say it was the right decision from both economic and humanitarian perspectives.
In a press release one day after the budget, Conservative Party immigration critic Michelle Rempel Garner slammed the measure, accusing the Liberals of a “hidden mass immigration agenda” to enrich their “wealthy corporate friends.”
Parisa Mahboubi, an economist with the C.D. Howe Institute, said in an e-mail that the government’s decision to add 200,000 permanent resident transitions outside the headline target of 380,000 ends up masking how many people Canada will actually admit as permanent residents in 2027.
“Repeating one-time initiatives such as that also signals that temporary residents who arrive and stay will eventually receive permanent status, which undermines efforts to reduce the number of non-permanent residents,” she said.
But regardless of the one-time measure, Ottawa is still trying to reduce temporary-resident levels to 5 per cent of the total population by the end of 2027. It is currently at 6.7 per cent and the government has committed to a temporary-resident target of 370,000 admissions annually over the next three years. That’s far less than the 971,000 foreign workers and international students admitted at the peak of the immigration boom in 2023.
Ottawa’s stricter approach to immigration has made Canada a less attractive destination for overseas workers and international students. The 2026 temporary-resident target was 370,000, but as of the end of August, only 195,000 people had arrived, according to government data.
“What’s missing from the headlines is that less people are arriving in Canada. Far less than our immigration targets. And that is impacting population growth and economic growth,” said Syed Hussan, executive director for Migrant Workers Alliance for Change, a migrant advocacy organization.
Adam Hajji, director of the Immigration Council at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, said there is a misconception that granting more permanent-resident cards to immigrants already working in Canada increases the number of immigrants in the country. “It does not. These are people who have lived here for years and made Canada their home.”
The chamber spent much of this year lobbying Ottawa to loosen permanent-resident targets so that many work-permit holders already in the Canadian work force could stay here long term, and businesses could have certainty about their employees’ work status.
“We were very appreciative of the government’s move to grant 200,000 people permanent status. We had been getting numerous calls from businesses in our network saying they were losing workers due to the immigration crackdown and could not find replacements,” Mr. Hajji added….
Source: Why Ottawa’s move to grant 200,000 temporary residents permanent status is facing backlash