McQueen | Mark Carney should require ‘permanent residents’ to be more permanent
2026/11/19 Leave a comment
Number of days change doesn’t appear at first glance to violate mobility rights. Dissenting opinions welcome:
…A partial solution to restoring broad support for our immigration system would be to return to first principles and reform the very foundation of the permanent resident program. What’s the point of handing out a million new PR permits over the next 24 months if these lucky individuals are required to spend only 146 days per year in Canada over the next five years, as is currently the case? Let’s change that back to at least 181 days per year in Canada (as was the law for decades) and ensure they’re taxed as residents.
How can we benefit from their “needed skills” if they’re spending 60 per cent of the calendar year working or travelling abroad? Unlike in the United States, where the Green Card permanent residency program expires after 10 years, PR in Canada is for life.
When the new targets were announced, Carney said temporary residents have been working for the same employers and living in the same communities for years, making them permanent residents “in all respects.”
One key step toward restoring confidence in the immigration system would be to require “permanent residents” to spend at least 181 days per year in Canada (as was the case for decades) and to be taxed as residents.
If these workers are truly essential to “Build Canada Strong,” then prove it. Surely it’s not too much to require our new peers to actually live and pay tax in Canada?
Source: Opinion | Mark Carney should require ‘permanent residents’ to be more permanent
