Barutciski: The U.S. wants to refocus the UNHCR. It’s the right thing to do for refugees

On the broadening of refugee definitions and the risk of UNHCR (along with some advocacy groups IMO) not recognizing the political and practical limits in refugee receiving countries:

…For Washington to achieve the reform it seeks, it needs to encourage greater candour from other governments concerned about migration control, and call for more realism from stakeholders. Canada could play a constructive role here. Instead, Ottawa used the Executive Committee meeting to proudly boastthat its delegation included “refugee voices,” before voting for the General Assembly draft resolution last week. The dissonance of such showboating is particularly obvious given that earlier this year, Ottawa quietly adopted Bill C-12, a law that introduces tighter eligibility rules in domestic asylum procedures after recent record numbers.

If the UNHCR is unable to help donor governments with their immediate migration crises – from boat crossings on the Mediterranean Sea and the English Channel to surges at the U.S.’s southern border and Quebec’s Roxham Road – then it has shifted too far toward a development approach that essentially distributes aid to poor countries housing many of the world’s refugees. It would also suggest that many humanitarians are treating recent Western funding pullbacks as a temporary pause led by a lame-duck U.S. administration, rather than a fundamental global reset. This would be misreading the room: Both the German and Canadian governments, for example, have contributed to the UNHCR’s multibillion-dollar funding cut amid real fiscal pressures and new defence priorities.

Serious UNHCR reform would recognize that its mandate involves solving tough asylum dilemmas, allowing it to remain relevant to both rich and poor countries. Should UNHCR refuse to change course, it will inevitably decline into a diminished, marginalized bystander. Canada has a chance to help stop this – but only if it stops using the refugee issue as an opportunity for self-promotion on the world stage and does the work that’s really needed.

Source: The U.S. wants to refocus the UNHCR. It’s the right thing to do for refugees

Unknown's avatarAbout Andrew
Andrew blogs and tweets public policy issues, particularly the relationship between the political and bureaucratic levels, citizenship and multiculturalism. His latest book, Policy Arrogance or Innocent Bias, recounts his experience as a senior public servant in this area.

One Response to Barutciski: The U.S. wants to refocus the UNHCR. It’s the right thing to do for refugees

  1. Raphael Solomon's avatar Raphael Solomon says:

    If the UNHCR is being reformed, could one fold UNRWA into it? The idea of someone being a refugee 3 or 4 generations after they were forced to leave their home is bizarre.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.