Immigration levels: Various Reactions

Variety of reactions that represent some of the positions, including the general pushback against the narrative of an increase (Coyne, Lorinc), more criticism of the slight of hand (Potter) and Maddeaux on possible gender impacts:

…All in all, it is not quite the “backlash” the immigration hysterics have been banking on. Canadians seem well able to distinguish between a short-term administrative snafu and immigration in general.

Well, there has been a backlash among one group: Conservatives. Liberal and Conservative voters used to hold broadly similar views on immigration. The gap between their perceptions started to emerge in the 2010s, and now stands at 44 points: 80 per cent of Conservatives now think there is too much immigration, versus 36 per cent of Liberals (and 20 per cent of New Democrats).

Can it be that immigration’s alleged harms have only affected Conservative voters? Have only Conservatives been priced out of the housing market, or made to wait for surgery, or lost their job, or any of the other things that are now routinely blamed on immigrants, despite abundant evidence to the contrary? (An example: house prices took off in 2000, long before the immigration boom, and fell all through it. They are now down nearly 30 per cent from their early 2022 peak.)

Or is this yet another example of the epistemic crisis, the soup of online disinformation through which a good part of the population now views the world?

I get why Conservative politicians are pandering to this, or indeed contributingto it. I’m not sure why so many pundits seem inclined to join them.

Source: Coyne: The real immigration ‘fib’? Far fewer migrants are entering Canada than official figures say

…So if the case for raising immigration targets now on labour market grounds is increasingly weak, what is motivating Carney’s rather sudden decision to “resume some controlled increase in the population?” What justifies the actual numbers? No one in the government seems interested in explaining what is going on. Instead, what we’re seeing is the return of a familiar Liberal tic of what could charitably be called fudging the facts. Justin Trudeau governed this way for the better part of a decade, communicating by half truths, fibs, and empty slogans until he ended up reflexively lying to Canadians whenever he couldn’t be bothered trying to explain the truth.

It’s a worse habit in Carney than it ever was in Trudeau, for the simple reason that Carney’s entire political brand is that he’s the Serious Guy. Canadians didn’t elect him for his last name or his good hair or emo rizz; they elected him because they believed he was a man who could be trusted to tell them the hard truths, whether it is about the economy, the federation, or the Americans. Snowing the country on immigration blows that credibility on the one file where the public has made it clear that trust is the whole game.

The issue isn’t whether 662,000 new permanent residents is too many, too few, or just right — reasonable people can disagree about that. The question is why the government felt it had to pretend the number was 380,000. One possibility is they think the real number is the appropriate target, but they don’t think they can make a convincing case for it to Canadians. The other possibility is that they know the real number is too high, that they don’t really have things under control, and have decided it’s not worth trying. And certainly not something they’re willing to admit.

Either way, this is not how you rebuild what remains a very shaky consensus on immigration. The glue that binds our increasingly diverse and multicultural society together, which serves as the catalyst for cooperation, stability, and social cohesion, is trust. But trust is hard won and easily lost, and a government that doesn’t trust Canadians enough to tell them what it is up to on immigration is playing a very dangerous game.

Source: Andrew Potter: “Serious Guy” Carney needs to tell the truth on immigration

….The key take-away with this announcement, in my view, is that the government is enabling people who are here — and, critically, who want to be here but have over-stayed work or education visas — to find a path to permanent residency. Canada needs immigrants, for all sorts of reasons — economic, demographic, cultural, and so on.

There’s nothing to fear in a tried and tested approach — regularization — that simply acknowledges the untidy reality that rigid immigration rules have a way of ensnaring people who came here not expecting to stay, but then discovered they actually wanted to build their lives here, for all sorts of reasons.

We need only look to our neighbour to the south to see what happens when the state becomes more fixated on removing quote-unquote illegal or undocumented migrants than with providing them with a path to citizenship. More importantly, we can look to the best moments of our own immigration history to see why this alternative approach is a better and more humane solution, and one that ultimately benefits Canada.

Source: Lorinc | Mark Carney is allowing 200,000 people to become permanent residents. Here’s why that should come as no surprise

…As temporary residents grew to a larger share of the overall population, and often became less temporary, the short- and long-term impacts amplified. Just as the federal Liberals failed to consider how rapid, loosely-planned immigration surges would distort housing markets, access to health care, and unemployment, they failed to account for the country’s gender balance.

In 2024, Statistics Canada reported the ratio among temporary residents had become untethered at between 126.6 to 133.1 men per 100 women in recent years. The temporary foreign worker program alone skews 58 per cent male.

The impacts show up most heavily in regions that welcome the most temporary residents, such as Windsor, which now counts 127 to 100 women in the 25-44 age bracket. Cities like Kitchener-Waterloo and Sudbury have seen similar jumps.

The issue isn’t just a matter of balancing numbers, but the economic, social, and political consequences of male surpluses.

In addition to the usual pressures that higher immigration places on labour markets, there’s even more competition among young men for work even as they continue to experience historically high unemployment outside of the pandemic years. And beyond the math on jobs, there’s also some basic life math ”

“In addition to the usual pressures that higher immigration places on labour markets, there’s even more competition among young men for work even as they continue to experience historically high unemployment outside of the pandemic years. And beyond the math on jobs, there’s also some basic life math that’s perhaps even more worrying. A large number of excess males means many won’t be able to find romantic partners, marry, or have families.

We know large numbers of un- or under-employed young men who are also single, and not by choice, are a recipe for trouble. Loneliness and aimlessness turn to resentment and bitterness, which easily turn to anger and radicalization. Crime rates often rise, and political instability follows.

Younger men in Canada report declining mental health, increased mood and anxiety disorders, and increased behavioural and addictions risk. They’re already a demographic in crisis, which unbalanced immigration adds even more pressure to.

Source: Sabrina Maddeaux: Liberal immigration skews wildly male. They call it ‘gender balanced’ anyway

Unknown's avatarAbout Andrew
Andrew blogs and tweets public policy issues, particularly the relationship between the political and bureaucratic levels, citizenship and multiculturalism. His latest book, Policy Arrogance or Innocent Bias, recounts his experience as a senior public servant in this area.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.