Immigration critics urge Liberals to come up with answers on asylum issue

Clearly becoming more of a wedge issue, with parties more interested in scoring points and inflaming debate rather than more serious discussion of the opportunities and constraints.

Tone and words matter, and some of the language and approach by federal and provincial conservatives is unhelpful. Stating valid concerns over the number of asylum seekers and the government’s approach could easily be done in a more neutral manner, just as the concerns over FGM, “honour killings” and the like be discussed without the label “barbaric cultural practices:”

With tensions over asylum seekers mounting between Ottawa and Ontario Premier Doug Ford’s new Progressive Conservative government, Conservative MP Michelle Rempel wants to give provincial immigration ministers another chance to air their grievances – and Lisa MacLeod says she’d happily do so.

As Mr. Ford’s community and social services minister, Ms. MacLeod is butting heads with the Liberal government over its handling of the asylum-seeker issue, and she was at it again Friday after the main federal, provincial and territorial players gathered for a meeting on the matter in Winnipeg.

She walked out of the meeting after a testy exchange with federal Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen, who later publicly accused Ontario of fear-mongering on asylum seekers. She called his comments “mean-spirited” and demanded an apology.

At Monday’s emergency meeting of the House of Commons immigration committee, opposition members will try to put some political pressure on the government by urging their Liberal counterparts to examine the problem, as well as the pressure it is putting on provinces.

Ms. Rempel will introduce a motion calling on the committee to “undertake a study to review the adequacy of the federal government’s response to the impact of increased asylum seekers crossing into Canada from the United States.”

She and NDP immigration critic Jenny Kwan are calling on the committee to hold two more meetings this summer in hopes of learning more about what the government intends to do.

The motion calls on Mr. Hussen to testify, for the committee to meet at least twice more this summer and that the study be concluded before Aug. 3. Ms. Rempel also wants provincial ministers to either testify or provide written submissions to the committee.

Ms. MacLeod said she’d happily oblige.

Ms. Rempel called for Monday’s meeting after hearing Ontario and Quebec say they’ve run out of room for migrants. The Ontario government said it is facing a “looming crisis” next month if Ottawa doesn’t help find space for refugees and asylum seekers currently sheltered in college dorms.

Mr. Ford has demanded the federal government foot the entire bill for the province’s costs. The federal government has so far offered $11-million in help.

“If we’re going to be allocating all of these funds and they’re unbudgeted, then the government should be able to table some sort of plan, and I do feel it’s been very piecemeal and reactive,” said Ms. Rempel.

“I don’t think we can wait until the fall because I think the situation is going to get worse.”

Canada’s Safe Third Country agreement with the U.S. stipulates that asylum seekers are required to make their claims in the first “safe” country where they arrive – meaning those who cross into Canada at an official land border crossing are sent back to make their claim in the U.S.

The agreement does not cover “irregular” or “illegal” asylum seekers – those entering Canada at unofficial points, most notably in Quebec.

The number of asylum seekers crossing between legal entry points has steadily decreased. According to new numbers released Friday, the RCMP intercepted 1,263 people at the border in June, which is down from 1,869 in May. In April, the RCMP intercepted 2,560 people at the border.

While committee chair Liberal MP Rob Oliphant won’t have a vote, he suggested he would be keen to hold additional meetings, if only to latch on to some facts to help to dispel any myths or “outrageous” claims that are circulating.

“That’s my duty,” Mr. Oliphant said. “I would say it’s best to get a hearing of the facts, get the evidence, find out what’s going on. That’s my personal opinion. Committee will make the decision. The more information the better and the sooner the better.”

Even so, the influx of asylum seekers crossing into Canada is an important issue, but not a crisis, Mr. Oliphant added.

“I’m going to be pushing that we have the right meetings at the right time with the right people to get the right information.”

Mr. Oliphant said he hasn’t yet spoken with the Liberal members of the committee, but their contingent usually meets before committee to discuss what they’re thinking “in terms of a team.”

The members listen to the opposition’s arguments, he insisted, and will come up with a decision after that.

For her part, Ms. Kwan – like Ms. Rempel – also has a slew of questions for Mr. Hussen and his officials. But she also said the committee needs to find a strategy to deal with the U.S., where President Donald Trump’s hard line on immigration is being blamed for pushing people north.

“As long as Trump is in office, the United States is not a safe country for asylum seekers,” Ms. Kwan said.

Source: Immigration critics urge Liberals to come up with answers on asylum issue

About Andrew
Andrew blogs and tweets public policy issues, particularly the relationship between the political and bureaucratic levels, citizenship and multiculturalism. His latest book, Policy Arrogance or Innocent Bias, recounts his experience as a senior public servant in this area.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: