Critics accuse the Conservative Party of ‘politicizing history’ as national museum mandates change | National Post

More debate on the mandate of the new national history museum. Removal of the phrase ‘critical understanding’ is significant, and reflects a change in substance and tone. Ironic, given one of the valid criticisms of the Canada Hall was its Disneyland-like airbrushing of Canadian history.

All governments struggle with how to cover and portray their history and the balance between reinforcing a national narrative while being honest about the less uplifting parts. See Margaret MacMillan’s The Uses and Abuses of History for a great discussion and examples

via Critics accuse the Conservative Party of ‘politicizing history’ as national museum mandates change | National Post.

Conservatives not the only political players to keep ‘enemies list’ | Columnists | Opinion | Toronto Sun

Fair point by Monte Solberg.

Conservatives not the only political players to keep ‘enemies list’ | Columnists | Opinion | Toronto Sun.

Cabinet orders add to confusion over Canada’s multiple multiculturalism ministers – Inside Politics

More on the ‘who is in charge’ question re multiculturalism between Minister Kenney, Alexander and Minister of State Uppal.

Cabinet orders add to confusion over Canada’s multiple multiculturalism ministers – Inside Politics.

Memo to Chris Alexander, Canada’s new immigration minister | Toronto Star

The contrary view to Minister Kenney’s achievements as Minister of Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism. Not a balanced take, but highlights the challenges of defining and finding balance given the range of interests and perspectives.

Memo to Chris Alexander, Canada’s new immigration minister | Toronto Star.

Chris Selley: Resisting multiculturalism, one packed lunch at a time | National Post

Yet another eruption over what should be a non-issue – bringing halal or kosher food to an amusement park. And fairness does not have to mean identical treatment.

Chris Selley: Resisting multiculturalism, one packed lunch at a time | National Post.

Critics want to see Harper government’s ‘enemy’ list | Toronto Star

More on the ‘enemies list,’ including my take.

Critics want to see Harper government’s ‘enemy’ list | Toronto Star.

The good old days of the public service – Secretary of State Department

Some of the history from the 70s and 80s on the work and times of the former Secretary of State department (folded into Canadian Heritage in 1993). Like many trips down memory lane, the memories may be somewhat selective, but having seen the integration of the Multiculturalism Program into CIC, and the relative weakness of the Citizenship Program in CIC’s centre of gravity, this does give a sense of how government priorities have changed, and identity-related files weakened.

The good old days of the public service.

Not a place to divide enemies and friends – The Globe and Mail

In the ongoing saga of the relationship between the political and bureaucratic levels,  the ‘friends and enemies’ list continues to attract comment.

My forthcoming book, Resetting Citizenship and Multiculturalism, recounts my experience. It was not without challenges but the bureaucracy needed to be challenged as it was overly comfortable with existing stakeholders, as well as and acknowledging the different and often valid perspective of the political level. The inverse also applied. Tone makes a difference, and finding the balance between being clear and direct, or being blunt and dismissive, remains a challenge.

Not a place to divide enemies and friends – The Globe and Mail.

Jason Kenney to maintain hold on ethnic file despite move to jobs portfolio | canada.com

More comments on the understandable decision to keep Jason Kenney responsible for the multiculturalism file, although it does mean a further diminishing of the multicultural program when the political and bureaucratic roles are divided between Ministers and departments.

Jason Kenney to maintain hold on ethnic file despite move to jobs portfolio | canada.com.

Why immigration and jobs were the most important changes in the cabinet shuffle – The Globe and Mail

Lots of media comment on the Cabinet shuffle. Some initial points of note from where I sit:

  • The focus at CIC will largely be on implementation, given the remarkable breadth and depth of Minister Kenney’ legislative, policy, program and service resetting;
  • As a result, Minister Alexander will likely find himself dealing more with implementation issues, some foreseen, some not foreseen, given that the impact of policy changes take time to show themselves (e.g., the temporary foreign workers file and perverse incentives to companies for outsourcing);
  • While the pillars of citizenship renewal are sound (more rigorous study guide, test, language and residency requirements), poor implementation has resulted in a 37 percent drop in new Canadian citizens in 2012. While the influx of new money in Budget 2013 should improve things, it does signify a systemic and ongoing issue regarding program management that will require Ministerial involvement.
  • One gap in CIC policy renewal remains citizenship legislation, given the act dates from 1977 and has long needed a major revamp and modernization. A mini-package fell on the order paper in 2011 and it will be interesting to see whether something more ambitious emerges this fall under the Speech from the Throne.
  • Multiculturalism continues its decline given the nature of CIC’s structure and centre of gravity. It will be interesting over time to see if some of Ministerial language shifts somewhat, given that some clearly had a very personal stamp by Minister Kenney.
  • While the article below suggests the all important ethnic community outreach file will be Minister Alexander’s, subsequent articles suggest that it will remain with Minister ‘Curry in a Hurry’ Kenney,

Why immigration and jobs were the most important changes in the cabinet shuffle – The Globe and Mail.