Who Speaks for a New Canadian Community? – New Canadian Media – NCM

Good reflections on media and public spokesman for different communities (also applies to groups within the “mainstream”):

When I produce religious and spiritual TV, I can usually locate pious types with an agenda of growth or political advancement, eager to proclaim their messages.  In fact, they find me before I find them. It’s not so easy to find ground-level community types who include women and youths in their productions.  It is harder animating liberal voices.

It’s too easy to mischaracterize a community by who comes forward to speak for it.   Media coverage and official political acknowledgement imparts a sort of legitimacy.  You have to wonder, without media coverage would there have been prominence for such figures and organizations as the Rev. Al Sharpton in the U.S., or the late Dudley Laws in Canada, Canadian Punjabi separatist groups, and the official-sounding, yet marginal, Canadian Islamic Congress?

In all cases, part of their credibility derived from savvy use of the media.  The media are willing participants.  Some lazy reporters and producers choose guests and sources on the basis of who is readily available on a moment’s notice, who’s articulate, or worse yet, who has the most anti-social, outrageous or activist point of view.

It is in our nature to be drawn to radical voices. Many of us love a fight.

Thus the militant voices start to punch far above their weight.  The mainstream starts to accord them special status that they haven’t really earned.

Who Speaks for a New Canadian Community? – New Canadian Media – NCM.

Not all ethnic media outlets keen to pose with PM – Politics – CBC News

Good article by Kady O’Malley on the government’s approach to ethnic media, part of their outreach to ethnic communities. Strong comments by Madeline Zinick, Canadian Ethnic Media Association chair and Omni TV vice-president (one of the main TV stations offering program in numerous languages):

“Generally, those journalists who are aggressive, and who like to do analysis and be challenging to the PM or any politician, more and more, they aren’t enjoying this kind of cattle call gong show approach,” she told CBC News.

According to Zinick, before the holidays Harper, who skipped his annual Christmas reception for the parliamentary press gallery, was the guest of honour at what his office billed as an “intimate family event” in Toronto, to which key “media leaders” were encouraged to bring members of their families in lieu of a TV crew.

“No cameras, no photos, no audio … you can’t report it in any way. Everyone had to wait in the holding area until Harper and his wife [Laureen] appeared, and there were no questions, just individual photos.”

Given those restrictions, Zinick says, “Why go and waste your time?”

Previous governments also courted the ethnic media (as do all political parties). However, previous governments did not spurn the national media to this extent by limiting media access.

Not all ethnic media outlets keen to pose with PM – Politics – CBC News.

Inside Stephen Harper’s ‘secret ethnic media’ session: Tim Harper | Toronto Star

In the vein of “Shopping for Votes,” this piece on the Conservative strategy with ethnic media is revealing but not terribly surprising. Previous governments also cultivated ethnic media to reach the diverse communities that comprise Canada, but generally did so in conjunction with a more open attitude to the national media.

His reluctance to sit down and talk about issues with the national media may not be puzzling but his view on the role of the ethnic media is troubling.

It is not our role, whether we represent The Toronto Star or Asian Star Weekly, to play a “vital” role in getting the government’s message out.

Both Liberals and Progressive Conservatives once played a variation of this game, giving priority to local reporters on trips outside Ottawa, in the belief they would toss softer questions to their leader.

That blew up when the local reporters decided they didn’t want to play that role and asked tougher questions than the Ottawa gang.

If Harper really thinks the ethnic media are there to help him deliver an unfiltered message, one of them is going to rise up and bite him before anyone poses for any pictures.

Inside Stephen Harper’s ‘secret ethnic media’ session: Tim Harper | Toronto Star.

Shoestring Ethnic Publications Say They Need Federal Cash, Ads: Survey » The Epoch Times

No surprise that ethnic media is also sharing some of the general challenges of the industry.

Shoestring Ethnic Publications Say They Need Federal Cash, Ads: Survey » The Epoch Times.