The Jobs You’re Most Likely to Inherit From Your Mother and Father – The New York Times
2017/11/27 Leave a comment
Interesting analysis:
When children choose what to be when they grow up, they often follow in their fathers’ footsteps. But mothers are powerful, too.
Working sons of working fathers are, on average, 2.7 times as likely as the rest of the population to have the same job but only two times as likely to have the same job as their working mothers, according to an analysis by The New York Times, one of the first to look at mothers and daughters in addition to fathers and sons. Daughters are 1.8 times as likely to have the same job as their mothers and 1.7 times as likely to have the same job as their fathers.
How often a man has the same job as his: Father 2.7× as likely Mother 2.0× as likely
How often a woman has the same job as her: Father 1.7× as likely Mother 1.8× as likely Try these jobs to start: Bartenders, cashiers, elementary and middle school teachers, lawyers, doctors and structural iron and steel workers. Some jobs are not available due to low sample size.
The estimates, drawn from General Social Survey data between 1994 and 2016, show that mothers, despite working in lower numbers, are still influential in inspiring their children’s career choices. And the passing down of occupation and other measures of socioeconomic status seems to affect boys more than girls.
Some of the jobs most likely to be passed down include steelworker, legislator, baker, lawyer and doctor. Children are less likely to follow their parents’ careers if they are middle managers or clerical or service workers. These findings broadly align with previous research.
“It’s not just a matter of education or what your parents can buy — there’s something about the occupations themselves,” said Kim Weeden, chairwoman of the sociology department at Cornell University, who is researching the topic with April Sutton, also a sociologist.
It’s another example of the powerful role family circumstances play in shaping children’s lives. Children with unemployed parents were more likely to say they didn’t know what they wanted to do for work, they found. “There’s an inheritance of advantage but also disadvantage when you talk about occupational plans,” Ms. Weeden said.
A big factor in passing down occupations — and advantage or disadvantage — is the connections parents offer children. Children who pursue the same job as their parents often start ahead, whether through inheriting a family business, getting an internship at a parent’s company or having a parent put in a good word with a colleague.
“If people lack financial capital, they likely lack these other types of capital as well,” said Claudia Goldin, an economist at Harvard. “For all of these reasons, the world is not a very fair place for some kids.”
Some fields are particularly dynastic, like Hollywood acting or politics.
…Children often pursue their parents’ jobs because of the breakfast-table effect: Family conversations influence them. They fuel interests or teach children what less commonly understood careers entail (probably one reason textile spinning and shoemaking are high on the list of jobs disproportionately passed on to children). In interviews, people who followed their parents’ career paths described it as speaking the same language.
Certain aptitudes may be inherited. Families also have their own cultures, reflected in how they value spending time — whether making things by hand, achieving academically or filling the home with art and music. People described flirtations with other careers as teenage rebellions before settling into a parent’s occupation.
How Frequently Do Daughters Share an Occupation With Their Parents?
Father
Fishers 362x as likely
Textile machine operator 159 Medical and laboratory techs 126 Aircraft mechanics 118 Librarians 106 Printing press operators 91 Packaging machine operators 39 Electrical, electronics and electromechanical assemblers 28 Lawyers 27 Doctors 19 Mother
Military officer 281x as likely
Shoemakers 135 Metal and plastic workers 105 Dishwashers 91 Human resources managers 78 Textile machine operator 75 Textile workers 65 Textile winding and twisting machine operators 60 Factory workers, food preparation 49 Travel agents 48 …Though research has focused more on fathers, mothers have always influenced their children’s career paths, social scientists say. “What we’re learning is that both parents are quite important, and quite important for both boys and girls,” Ms. Weeden said.
In our analysis, sons are 20 times as likely to be a scientist if their mother is one. Gil Rabinovici is the son of Sarah Bacus, a cancer scientist, and Eliezer Rabinovici, a theoretical physicist. After giving up the idea of becoming the next Steven Spielberg or playing third base for the Chicago Cubs, he became a neurologist, studying memory disorders at the University of California, San Francisco.
How Frequently Do Sons Share an Occupation With Their Parents?
Father
Textile machine operator 415x as likely
Boilermakers 275 Fishers 275 Drywall installers 136 Structural iron and steel workers 135 Door-to-door sales workers 130 Cabinetmakers 127 Prepress technicians and workers 116 Textile workers 105 Railroad conductors 94 Mother
Paralegals and legal assistants 191x as likely
Bakers 66 Credit counselors and loan officers 58 Postal service clerks 43 Clinical laboratory techs 38 Bartenders 36 Hairdressers 26 Butchers 24 Packaging machine operators 18 Child care workers 16 “I think seeing work for them growing up as a passion rather than a chore is something I’m sure had an influence on me,” he said.
The effect of his mother’s science career has been intergenerational, he said: His 9-year-old daughter spends time drawing neurons and brain schematics. “It definitely influenced how I view gender, and probably having a strong role model as a scientist influenced her,” he said.
…Yet over all, parents have less of an effect on daughters than on sons, in career and socioeconomic status more broadly, according to research.
One explanation is that previous generations of mothers had fewer job options than their daughters, so their daughters consider a broader range of jobs. Men, meanwhile, are unlikely to take jobs that haven’t typically been done by men.
Because daughters are less likely to work or earn as much, parents might invest more in sons’ careers. But more likely, researchers said, parents invest equally, and women make more career compromises because of family obligations. Especially with young children, some women “can’t do the jobs that they wanted or were trained to do by their parents,” said Melinda Morrill, an economist at North Carolina State University.
The General Social Survey analysis is not conclusive. For instance, because of the small sample size, we could not control for age, which matters when considering how women’s careers are affected by motherhood. The survey may also misclassify the dominant career of the parent. Survey respondents were asked only what their parents’ latest occupation was, so if the parent was a steelworker in the prime of his career, but now is a greeter at Walmart, the survey would classify him as a greeter. The same is true if the parent is now retired.
Also, it is impossible to isolate the influences of parents. But we know that children inherit economic standards of living from their parents, and the occupations of parents are one determinant of the American dream — whether children are better off than they were.
via The Jobs You’re Most Likely to Inherit From Your Mother and Father – The New York Times
